Archive for April, 2005

Quis custodiet custodiens?

Tuesday, April 12th, 2005

The following is the text of a letter I sent to the editor of the Irish Times on the 11th March, 2005. To my knowledge, the Irish Times didn’t publish it.

=====================

The Guildford Four, the Maguire Seven and the Birmingham Six were all imprisoned for lengthy sentences on terrorist charges that were eventually shown to have been false.

In November 2004, at the behest of the Governments of Italy and Switzerland, the FBI raided the data centre of the Indymedia organisation in the UK, under the pretence of a counter-terrorism investigation. The disks confiscated appear to have contained information relating to Indymedia’s investigations of Italian and Swiss police agents who are alleged to have been attempting to stir-up violence during so-called anti-globalisation protests.

In March of 2004, Adam McGaughey, of the fan website SG1Archive.com was charged with breaking U.S. federal copyright laws. The USA PATRIOT Act was used to facilitate the FBI investigation. Intended as a measure to protect the public from terrorist threats, the USA PATRIOT Act allows investigators to operate in ways that would be prohibited under other legislation. Its measures are, one by one, being invalidated as being counter to the US Constitution. Yet, the provisions were used to investigate a copyright case, and at the behest of MGM and the Motion Picture Association of America.

In 1996, the American Society of Composers, Authors & Publishers (ASCAP) demanded royalty money from, among others, Girl Scouts for singing songs around campfires.

(more…)

Innovation for the sake of….. innovation

Tuesday, April 12th, 2005

On the 18th March this year, there was a “Commercial” supplement to the Irish Times celebrating Microsoft’s 20 years of operations in Ireland. In it, there was a piece featuring Cathal Friel, Chairperson of the Irish Software Association, who made some rather disparaging comments about “open source” and those who develop Free Software.

Many on the fora I contribute to (ILUG, the Irish Linux Users’ Group and IFSO, the Irish Free Software Organisation) were offended by the comments. Some of the responses involved writing to the editor of the Irish Times to complain about the bias shown in the article. This is a fair attempt to set the record straight, but I knew it would be unlikely to succeed because we’re dealing with a commercial supplement: the Irish Times was probably paid a great deal of money by Microsoft and its partners. Wouldn’t do to offend that revenue stream, now would it?

Therefore, I decided to send a letter to Mr. Friel himself, objecting to the piece. Below is the text of that letter, re-edited into the format of a response piece. I wanted to remove any personal identifying information and to remove the second-person grammar. In the letter, however, I asked Mr. Friel to consider his statement and, if he wished, to respond to my correspondence.

On Holy Thursday, as I was stuck in traffic on what turned out to be a gruelling 10-hour journey to Cork from Dublin, I received a ‘phone call from Kathryn Raleigh, Director of the ISA, in reponse to my letter. (more…)